Open Inbox Anonymous Answers

WTMP is hosting an Open Inbox from January 1 - March 30! Through that open inbox, we have a form that allows authors to submit anonymous questions. You can find those questions and the mentor’s answers here! The full archive of answers is below. You can also search the various questions for keywords (ex. agents, querying, betas, contracts, etc.)

Samira F Samira F

Question 20

Would Agents reject an adult romance contemporary novel based on word count?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 19

I am stuck at 55k words in my romcom. I am struggling to continue. Looking at my book, it can only get to 70k. Is that acceptable? Any advice?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 18

What does it mean if there is too much happening in the plot?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 17

I'm taking break between drafts (this is 6th draft), how long should I wait and does that mean I shouldn't do other related stuff like aesthetics or research?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 16

I'm about to start querying. I was going over my list of agents and realized both of the agents who rep the comp titles mentioned in my query are on my to-query list. Is it okay to query the agents of your comp titles?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 15

I’m struggling in my writing process. There are tons of references for plotting and other elements of story craft. But I can’t find much that provides guidance for HOW to outline. Can you offer any advice or any references you may have found? Thanks in advance!

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 14

Any suggestions for dealing with the massive amounts of rejections that come with querying?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 13

As a white-passing latina, I have a question about representation. I understand the desire for characters who share identities with the author, but in multi-POV stories, does the publishing world frown upon POVs from characters of color whose experiences I don’t share? I have a 4 POV heist story I’m working on (think Six of Crows) and I don’t want to only have white latinas like myself, I also want to write Afro-Latina POVs, but im not sure if that’s frowned upon?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 12

A lot of writers find themselves getting form rejections to their query. How do you feel about the practice of using test agents to determine if your submission package is working?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 11

My question is more logistical for writers. How do you prepare your manuscript for beta readers? What platform, if any, do you use to transfer/send to them to read? And do you have any settings in place to protect your work?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 10

I'm wondering about MG conventions regarding a novel's timeframe. Can books only take place over the course of a certain timeline--the shorter, the more engaging? Can a book about a school year take place throughout an entire year? Are you allowed to skip around, or should it be following day to day? Is a book involving a summer camp allowed to spill into a school year?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 9

When an agent says they're looking for BIPOC voices, does that include people of Asian descent? Is #ownvoices still a useful hashtag or are people moving away from it because of overuse/inappropriate usage? Are there ways to find a critique group or partner that don't involve trusting internet strangers? What is the best way to use a brief pitch session with an agent at a writing conference?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 8

Should I pay an editor to go through my MS before I query an agent, or is this something that can be done further down the line as part of a publishing deal?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 7

Besides AMM, Pitchwars, and Avengers of Color, what other mentorship programs are available? When do the submission periods open for those programs?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 6

What happens if an author's agent moves to a different literary agency? Does the author go with them automatically or do they have to choose? Also if, that author has sold a book with the agent at the previous agency, does that old agency still get a cut of the royalties?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 5

I am someone who can never write two manuscripts in the same genre. How would you recommend querying when the MS I have prepared isn’t necessarily the genre I want to stick with for the rest of my career? Should I try to find agents who represent all of the genres I write in, or hope that a good agent would be flexible with their clients? Do I mention this in the query letter, or wait until it comes up in a call?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 2.5

When you get an agent, does that agent stick with you and help you with your next book? Or do you need to find a new agent for every book you publish? Does this change if your first book is YA and your second is Adult? Thank you!

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 4

I keep hearing how important this is to do to write a strong manuscript. Can you suggest a few ways to increase tension at various places in a story?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 3

I love craft books, and I'd love to add more to my collection. Can you suggest any great craft books?

Read More
Samira F Samira F

Question 2

When you get an agent, does that agent stick with you and help you with your next book? Or do you need to find a new agent for every book you publish? Does this change if your first book is YA and your second is Adult?

Read More